The method of hierarchy analysis in the evaluation of classification features of hub transport organizational and technical systems

The article presents the author's approach to the selection and evaluation of classification features of hub transport organizational and technical systems (HTOTS) based on the proposed conceptual framework. The classification is based on five key features that reflect the dynamic and synergistic properties of HTOTS: the stage of the life cycle, the type of development dynamics, the ability to self-organize, the type of attractor, and the phase state. To determine the weighting significance of the classification features, the method of hierarchical analysis (MHA) by T. Saaty is used, which allows for a mathematical justification of their contribution to the integral assessment. The consistency ratio (CR = 0.017) confirms the consistency of the expert judgments. A hierarchical system of private indicators (23 indicators) has been developed to ensure objective evaluation. Based on the proposed methodology, fifty HTOTS of the Russian Federation were quantified, their integral development indices were obtained, and a ranking and comparative analysis were performed for the purposes of strategic planning of transport infrastructure development and management decision-making.

1. Transport Strategy of the Russian Federation until 2030 with a forecast for the period up to 2035 : approved by Order of the Government of the Russian Federation No. 3363-r dated November 27, 2021. – URL: http://static.government.ru/media/files/7enYF2uL5kFZlOOpQhLl0nUT91RjCbeR.pdf (date of access: 06/25/2026).

2. Mizgireva, E. E. Formation of a method for locating infrastructure facilities at transport hubs under fuzzy parameterization principles : specialty 2.9.1 “Transport and transport-technological systems of the country, its regions and cities, organization of production in transport (technical sciences)” : dissertation for the degree of Candidate of Technical Sciences / Mizgireva Ekaterina Evgenievna ; Rostov State Transport University. – Rostov-on-Don, 2025. – 235 p.

3. Kozlov, P. A. To the theory of transport nodes / P. A. Kozlov, V. Yu. Permikin, N. V. Kashcheeva // Transport of the Urals. – 2013. – No. 4 (39). – P. 8–10. – ISSN 1815-9400.

4. Pravdin, N. V. Design of railway transport infrastructure (stations, railway and transport hubs) / N. V. Pravdin, S. P. Vakulenko, A. K. Golovnich. – Moscow : Educational and Methodological Center for Railway Transport Education, 2012. – 1086 p. – ISBN 978-5-89035-619-2.

5. Sandakova, N. Yu. On the issue of using the theory of developing systems as a basis for the socioeconomic development of a region / N. Yu. Sandakova // Problems of Modern Economics. – 2014. – No. 2 (50). – P. 407–410. – ISSN 1818-3395.

6. Saaty, T. L. A scaling method for priorities in hierarchical structures / T. L. Saaty // Journal of Mathematical Psychology. – 1977. – Vol. 15, No. 3. – P. 234–281. – DOI 10.1016/0022-2496(77)90033-5.

7. Saaty, T. Decision making. The analytic hierarchy process / T. Saaty ; translated from English by R. G. Vachnadze. – Moscow : Radio i Svyaz, 1993. – 278 p.

8. Islam, R. The analytic hierarchy process in the transportation sector / R. Islam, T. L. Saaty // Multiple criteria decision making for sustainable energy and transportation systems / ed. by M. Ehrgott [et al.]. – Berlin : Springer, 2010. – P. 79–91. – (Lecture Notes in Economics and Mathematical Systems ; Vol. 634). – DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-04045-0_7.

9. Rassadnikova, E. Yu. Modified Saaty hierarchy method for the problem of selecting a transport mode / E. Yu. Rassadnikova // Vestnik of the Ufa State Aviation Technical University. – 2014. – Vol. 18, No. 5. – P. 146–152. – ISSN 1992-6502.

10. Saaty, T. L. Models, Methods, Concepts & Applications of the Analytic Hierarchy Process / T. L. Saaty, L. G. Vargas. – 2nd ed. – New York : Springer, 2012. – 346 p. – (International Series in Operations Research & Management Science ; Vol. 175). – DOI 10.1007/978-1-4614-3597-6.

11. Macromodeling of transport hubs / P. A. Kozlov, N. A. Tushin, V. Yu. Permikin, I. G. Slobodyanyuk // Railway Transport. – 2015. – No. 10. – P. 38–40. – ISSN 0044-4448.

12. On the principles of calculating transport hubs / P. A. Kozlov, S. P. Vakulenko, V. P. Kozlova, N. Yu. Evreenova // World of Transport and Transportation. – 2021. – Vol. 19, No. 4 (95). – P. 6–12. – DOI 10.30932/1992-3252-2021-19-4-1.

13. Voronov, V. A. Transport hubs and intermodal complexes. Terms and definitions / V. A. Voronov, K. Yu. Chistyakov // Architecture and Modern Information Technologies. – 2020. – No. 3 (52). – P. 252–264. – DOI 10.24411/1998-4839-2020-15214.

14. Rotter, H. New operating concepts for intermodal transport: The mega hub in Hanover/Lehrte in Germany / H. Rotter // Transportation Planning and Technology. – 2004. – Vol. 27, No. 5. – P. 347–365. – DOI 10.1080/0308106042000273022.

15. Sysoev, N. Yu. Development of industrial and transport hubs based on improving the interaction of public and non-public railway transport : speciality 2.9.4 “Transportation Process Management” : dissertation for the degree of Candidate of Technical Sciences / Sysoev Nikolay Yuryevich ; Russian University of Transport (MIIT). – Moscow, 2025. – 185 p.